1/17/2024 0 Comments Firefox focus android![]() This destroys the one single value that Firefox has in the current world: It’s not Google. That is the elephant in the room that everyone at mozilla tries to ignore by putting Google Analytics into the addon menu of Firefox (and, as result, also in the Tor browser), and by importing a Google Analytics library into Firefox Focus. If you ask people to trust Google, you’re literally telling them to just use Google Chrome. The entire reason anyone still uses Firefox is because they don’t trust Google. If I trusted Google to keep their word, I’d use Chrome.Ĭhrome runs far faster, looks better, is easier usable, has better addon support, works with more websites because everyone only supports Chrome anymore, it actually supports 10 bit video, oh, and it even does hardware video decoding on Linux. If you use Google Analytics in Firefox’ Addon menu, or in Firefox Focus, and say "but Google doesn’t technically track people because we have a contract with them", then I can just as well use Chrome. That I can exist without having to use Google’s technology. That I don’t even have any kind of interaction with Google. The whole purpose of Firefox is that I don’t have to trust Google. If you use Google proprietary software in Firefox, and tell people to just trust Google, you just entirely destroyed every value Firefox ever had, and your own job. Your entire userbase is people that don’t trust Google, at all. ![]() If people trusted Google, they’d use Google Chrome in the first place. I’m not sure if you’re trying to intentionally ignore the issue here. > Even Google has decent data collection policies. but you're sailing blind without this kind of data, and ultimately hurting both yourself and your users.) You need to know which issues are actually important, developers don't have infinite time (as much as we wish we did). Same story with crash reports (typically users have to explicitly confirm sending crash reports in many applications, no idea what kind of system Focus uses though). And makes it possible to justify retaining complex features that happen to be useful to many users. Knowing that a feature isn't used makes it easy to accurately remove crufty/complicated features without negatively impacting a lot of users. But in some cases features make app development more complicated (ALSA support in desktop firefox might be a better example, but I'm not super familiar with that case). to the toolbar if used a lot, or into a deeper menu if rarely used). Or whether moving it elsewhere is sensible (e.g. refresh pages a lot (or even, how can that data be sold)? OTOH it does let the developers know whether removing the refresh button would affect a lot of users. but what nefarious things can one do knowing that some anonymous user happens to e.g. (The more interesting question is: could Focus receive the INSTALL_REFERRER itself for ads attribution instead of using Adjust? That data might be meaningless without asking google to tell you where it came from, and they provided it in the first place anyway.) This is the only time play-services-analytics shuld be used, i.e. This only comes into play if you install the app from the play store (which funnily enough Google own). ![]() Adjust depends on play-services-analytics. This is only used to determine whether the app was installed as the result of a specific (google-hosted) ad campaign. Adjust SDK: an install attribution tool (aka install referrer tracking). This stuff is used for deciding what features to prioritise (or remove), and doesn't involve Google servers. do people use share, do people use custom tabs, do people clear using the bin button or the notification). This only sends data to Mozilla servers, and only concerns what features people use (i.e. ![]() Mozilla telemetry: enabled by default in Focus, disabled by default in Klar. Focus (for Android) doesn't use Google analytics directly, but it's an indirect dependency - see below. ![]()
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |